5 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Paydown Your Credit Cards

What type of debt should you paydown first? Ask your family, a financial planner, a blogger, or even someone off the street, and just about everytime they are going to tell you to pay off those credit cards!  Credit cards carry a very negative stigma, and deservedly so.  According to creditcards.com, the average credit card balance for all households that carry debt is $14,750.  What’s even worse, that balance carries an average interest rate of 13.67%.  Considering a minimum monthly payment of 2% of the balance, and it will take you over 50 years to pay it off.  Over those 50 years, that $14,750 will cost you over $19,000 in interest.  That 13.67% is over 2.5 times my mortgage rate, and more than twice as much as the rate attached to my student loans.  Yet despite these eye opening facts, there are still times when it’s NOT prudent to pay down those credit cards first.  Bet you didn’t see that coming, huh?  I’m going to give you 5 examples of when it’s alright to hold off on paying down those credit cards!

According to Credit Card Guide, in the 4th quarter of 2010, 52% of consumers who defaulted on debt were over 30 days behind on paying their mortgage.  Out of this same group of consumers, only 22% were behind on their credit card payments.  I’m not saying it’s alright to just shirk your financial responsibilities and allow your credit cards to go into default.  On the other hand, if you simply don’t have enough to pay both, then that money would be better spent on your dwelling.  Though unlikely, just one month in default can begin the eviction process for a homeowner or renter.  Credit card companies may wait months for a payment, they are also more apt to work out a payment plan, and they can’t throw you out on the street!

I have written about the dangers of student loans a few times, and for good reason.  Once acquired, these loans are with you for life, at least until you pay them in full.  This is one of the few types of debt that cannot be written off during a bankruptcy.  If you are falling behind on your payments, or feel that bankruptcy is inevitable, make sure you are allocating your funds wisely.  Don’t keep paying that mortgage if you know it’s going into foreclosure.  Don’t pay your credit cards if they are in default.  Apply those funds to that ball and chain we call student loans.

Another financial obligation that is impossible to shirk, and for good reason, are child support payments.  Being a child of divorced parents I was privy to this process first hand.  Despite the misfortunte of those who have to file bankruptcy, they will still have to make these payments before, during, and after the proceedings are done.  If you have limited available funds, would you rather that money go to credit card companies…or your children?  In a perfect world you would meet all your financial obligations, but considering the current state of our economy, we sometimes find ourselves picking and choosing.

The 0% APR cards are back and here to stay!  I would never advocate that you carry a balance on your card, but if you already are, then find yourself a 0% APR card.  I have a Discover More card with a promotional one year 0% interest rate.  Im not a stock guru, but even I can make some safe stock picks that will outpace 0%!  Continue to make your minimum monthly payments on your card, but use excess funds to invest in safe dividend paying stock, a one year CD, or even an aggressive money market account.  When the balance comes due, use those interest earning funds to pay it all off.

Finding extra money to apply to credit cards can be daunting.  I know in the past I tried selling items on ebay/amazon, cashing in change, cutting back on expenses, and even earning income online.  Now consider that the average tax refund in 2010 was over $3,000, or $250 per month.  For many people an extra $250 a month may put a nice dent in their credit card balances.  So why not improve your tax planning skills and use that money where it’s needed? Here’s why…because you won’t!  I know, I dont you, and I shouldn’t pretend that I do.  However, I do know that personal finance is at least 50% psychological, after all, there is a reason why you got yourself into debt in the first place.  If you start receiving that large lump sum annual refund in smaller monthly amounts, you will most likely spend it on things other than paying down your debt.  So you gave Uncle Sam an interest free loan, the opportunity cost is minimal.  When you receive that large annual refund, you will be more apt to use it on paying down your debt.  Seeing $3,000 knocked off your balance is a powerful thing, and it may motivate you to keep the ball rolling.

I hope you paid attention, because you wont see many personal finance enthusiasts giving you reasons NOT to paydown your credit cards.  I promise my next topic will be more financially responsible 🙂

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • Tipd
  • Tumblr

21 thoughts on “5 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Paydown Your Credit Cards

  1. kh

    So the argument is that you should pay the minimum on your credit cards and rack up the interest so that when you have to file bankruptcy you can get out of the maximum amount of debt?
    Um. Ok. Not buying that one, sorry. 😉

    1. admin Post author

      I definitely wouldnt say that you “should” do this, but some people find themselves in tough situations. You shouldnt get yourself into credit card debt, but I do feel that having a roof over your head and paying child support is more important than paying the credit card companies if you literally have no choice. I would never make a late payment, but loss of job, mounting medical bills, interest kicks in on the mortgage, etc… people find themselves in this situation a lot these days.

  2. MoneyCone

    Interesting (and controversial!) post! 🙂

    If I knew I’m going to file for bankruptcy, then yes, I’ll try to pay off my student loans first and not worry too much about my credit card payments!

    1. admin Post author

      Thanks! I was definitely going for controversial on this one…and it was a topic I hadnt seen before.

  3. ann @ merchant services

    People should know their limitations in using their credit cards. Reading this article made me realized how complicated the consequences are if I could not pay my debts up-to-date. Thanks for posting this.

  4. Melissa

    I agree, if you are in a difficult situation, this may be the best bet. More importantly, like you say, the credit card companies are often willing to negotiate. This isn’t a strategy for everyone, but it is important to prioritize like this in the case of job loss, etc.

    However, if someone is already behind on their credit card payments, they will probably find it difficult to get a 0% interest card.

  5. admin Post author

    I agree Melissa, the 0% interest card is more of a reason for those with excellent credit, but still carry a balance. I wouldnt rush to pay it off right away, rather, invest until the balance comes due and then pay it off.

  6. Evan

    My wife and I definately have a habit of expecting a large tax refund, and we have an idea of how we are going to spend that money. For example this year we did exactly as you said and paid off our credit cards. It makes a big difference at the end of the year to get a big amount instead of getting an extra 200 a month. Maybe in the future when we get better with money we would be able to change our tax situation to not give a “free” loan to the government, but in the meantime it is almost a bonus check for us when we do our taxes.

  7. Pingback: Yakezie Carnival – The Berkshire Hathaway 2011 Edition — Narrow Bridge Finance

  8. Pingback: Carnival of Personal Finance Mother's Day Edition

  9. Hunter

    Excellent post. I totally agree that when debtors need to discriminate between which accounts to pay, credit cards are at the bottom of the list. Having said that, it’s important to stop spending with those cards too. I also agree that if your house is going to be lost to foreclosure, STOP PAYING. Start to rebuild for your future because mortgage payments will be lost.

  10. Pingback: Totally Money Blog Carnival #18 | Totally Money Blog Carnival

  11. Marie

    Prioritize yes, avoid paying when you can – never! When you willingly take on debt, you can’t just shrug it off and say ‘oh well, I would have lost it in the foreclosure anyway!’

    1. admin Post author

      Im not saying avoid paying what you owe when the funds are readily available. Im simply saying to make the right choices when funds are limited. As I said above, statistics show that out of all the consumers who are defaulting on some form of debt, a majority are defaulting on mortgage payments and keeping current on their credit cards. I see a greater benefit, in terms of personal and economical, in paying your mortgage/rent over your credit card bill if left with no other choice.

  12. Ross @ Go Be Rich

    All it really comes down to is prioritizing. Of course, the optimal situation to be in would be one where you’re not forced to prioritize at all, but the reality is that sometimes this isn’t an option.

    I’m really a big believer in knowing yourself, and using that to decide what item of debt to pay off first. If you know you don’t have much of a history of sticking with difficult financial tasks, then I would say pay off the item of debt with the smallest balance first to gain some traction and confidence.

  13. Pingback: Totally Money Blog Carnival #18 – 6 Ways to Save Money Edition … | Credit Wise Info

  14. Samantha

    I agree, to an extent, but carrying a credit card balance still isn’t healthy. Also, the interest rate on student loans is a fraction of the rate on credit card debt.

  15. Pingback: Totally Money Blog Carnival #18 - TotallyMoney

  16. Pingback: Living the Cash Only Life

  17. Pingback: NET Goiania

  18. Pingback: Have You Ever Missed A Payment?

Comments are closed.